First Messages

First Messages That Get Responses

What to say when 'Hey' isn't enough but pickup lines feel wrong.

You matched with someone interesting. Now what? That blank message box is staring at you, and "Hey" feels lazy while pickup lines feel cringey.

Here's the thing: most people overthink first messages. You don't need to be Shakespeare or a comedian. You just need to give someone a reason to respond.

Why Most First Messages Fail

Before we talk about what works, let's address what doesn't:

  • "Hey" or "Hi" - Requires zero effort and shows you didn't read their profile
  • Generic compliments - "You're beautiful" could apply to anyone
  • Pickup lines - Most are overused and feel impersonal
  • Novels - Long messages can feel overwhelming
  • Interview questions - "How was your weekend?" puts pressure on them

The Formula That Works

Good first messages have three elements:

  1. Reference something specific from their profile
  2. Share something brief about yourself
  3. Ask an easy question or make a light comment

Here's how this looks in practice:

Their profile mentions hiking:
"I saw you're into hiking! I just discovered this trail near [local area] that has an amazing view at the top. Have you explored much around here?"

They have a photo with a dog:
"Your dog looks like trouble in the best way. My sister's golden retriever has that same 'I definitely didn't eat your shoes' expression."

They mention loving coffee:
"Fellow coffee person! I'm on a mission to find the best local roaster. Any recommendations, or are you team chain coffee?"

What Makes These Work

Notice what these messages do:

  • They show you actually looked at their profile
  • They reveal something about you without oversharing
  • They're easy to respond to
  • They feel conversational, not interrogational

When Their Profile Is Blank

Sometimes you'll match with someone who has minimal information. In these cases:

  • Comment on a photo (appropriately)
  • Ask about their location or interests
  • Share something interesting about your day

Example: "I'm trying to decide between pizza and tacos for dinner—clearly the important life decisions. How do you usually solve these dilemmas?"

Timing and Follow-Up

Send your message when you're genuinely interested, not because you feel obligated. If they don't respond within a few days, let it go. Double messaging rarely works and often comes across as pushy.

The Real Goal

Remember: your first message isn't trying to win them over completely. It's just trying to start a conversation. Keep it light, genuine, and focused on connection rather than impression.

The best first messages feel like something you'd say if you met this person at a coffee shop. Natural, friendly, and interested—but not trying too hard.